When did This Is Us jump the shark? 🦈

Season 3, Episode 8

The show introduced a controversial plot twist involving Nicky Pearson, Jack's brother, which many fans felt was inconsistent with earlier character development and narrative style. This plot device seemed forced and detracted from the show's authentic storytelling, marking a noticeable dip in audience engagement and satisfaction.

Confidence: 85%

We only add shows that have been around for more than one season. If you think we should have your search request, let us know and we'll review it.