When did Dexter jump the shark? 🦈

Season 5, Episode 1

Dexter is widely considered to have 'jumped the shark' at the start of Season 5, following the conclusion of the Trinity Killer arc and the death of Rita. This pivotal moment left the show struggling to find a new direction and maintain the high level of tension and character development that had been achieved in previous seasons. Subsequent plotlines failed to resonate as strongly with audiences, leading to a decline in critical reception.