When did Dexter jump the shark? 🦈

Season 5, Episode 1

Dexter is widely believed to have jumped the shark after the conclusion of Season 4, which featured the intense and critically acclaimed Trinity Killer arc. The premiere of Season 5 marked a decline, with many fans feeling that the show struggled to find its footing and maintain the same level of tension and character development. The introduction of less compelling storylines and new characters that didn't resonate as strongly contributed to the show's perceived decline.